I first saw this at a local grocery store I don’t normally shop at. I decided to try a bag. Two of my three cats weren’t interested but the one who was seemed to love it. I then noticed it at the closest BJs and bought two more bags. For whatever reason, the one cat who loved it seems to not care for it so much anymore. She’ll eat it but not like she did in the beginning. I checked the expiration dates and smelled it to make sure it didn’t smell like it had gone bad but I found nothing wrong with it. The only difference was the first bag was bought at a local grocery store where the two following bags were bought at BJs. Maybe I’ll buy another bag at the grocery store and see if it interests her again.